Sunday, June 28, 2015
When the Greek central bank prints Euros, they have a "Y" on them. Up till now these Greek Euros were exchanged 1 for 1 with any other Euros.
The Target2 system for electronic payments is how they kept all the different Euros values pegged to each other. However, if Greece no longer gets unlimited credit from the ECB the electronic Euros inside Greece can no longer be converted in unlimited amounts to Euros in other countries. The Greek Euros are sort of an island separate from other Euros. If Target2 does not work for Greece, then Greek Euros are no longer regular Euros.
The peg between Greek Euros and others is failing. No longer will Euros in Greek banks or Euros printed by the Greek central bank be as good. People will soon prefer to hold Euros with anything other than an "Y" or in banks outside Greece. Capital controls in Greece now limit how fast people can take Euros out of Greek banks, while the same ATM does not limit someone with an account in another country. Euros in Greek banks are not as good as Euros in banks in other countries. It could soon be that people outside Greece no longer accept Greek Euros. Where they are accepted, the Greek Euros could trade at a discount to other Euros. The worse things get the bigger the discount will become. Euros with an "Y" can become a separate special Greek only Euro, or effectively, Drachma.
As long as Greece was running a big deficit and on net getting more money each year from the Troika it made sense for it to do whatever was required of it. If Greece did not they would not have enough money to operate the government, since nobody else would loan them money. However, after getting to the point where they have a budget surplus and were going to be on net paying money to the Troika, they really can default and probably are better off to do so.
If a company could shed liabilities while still holding onto all its assets and sources of income, then it will be in a stronger financial position. Countries are similar when defaulting on external debts. Most of the time countries can default without any invasion or other real penalty. I don't expect Greece to be invaded because of their default.
When England and the USA defaulted on their promise to redeem their paper notes for gold the rest of the world was worse off and they were better off. It helped them get out of the Great Depression. In the short term Greece is no doubt in trouble, but in the longer term defaulting should remove a huge burden from their shoulders and leave their creditors worse off.
If Greek Euros are not equal to other Euros, it is as if "Greece has left the Euro". The market price for the Greek Euros will just be different than other Euros. This can happen fast without any deliberate action by any government. Maybe in the next few weeks.
We might see a "black market exchange" where a tourist coming into Greece could exchange their regular Euros for more local Euros. This could encourage tourism to Greece.
At some future point, when it is clear Greek Euros are no longer regular Euros, Greece could exchange Greek Euros for a newly issued Drachma.
If the Greek government keeps a nearly balanced budget the Greek Euros or Drachma should stabilize after an initial adjustment. If they start running big deficits in the near future, hyperinflation is a possibility.
We live in interesting times.
Update 7/4/15: An earlier version of this post said Euros with an "N" were from Greece. It seems this is the printer code and "Y" really means Greece. Thanks for commenter below pointing this out.
Wednesday, June 17, 2015
In 1803 the US paid $15 million for the Louisiana Purchase (white part in map below). Today this would be closer to $15 trillion. So maybe a factor of 1 million inflation.
By official inflation numbers this $15 million is $236 million in 2014 U.S. dollars. This is about a factor of 16 inflation.
Originally the dollar was defined as 1 oz of silver. Now silver is about $16 dollars/oz, or a factor of 16 inflation.
Gross public debt in 1800 was $83 million. Today gross public debt is $21.7 trillion. This is a factor of 261,000.
It is interesting that silver is only up by a factor of 16 and public debt is up by a factor of 261,000.
This reminds me of a movie where Dr Evil, who was frozen in the 1960s and then woken up in the present, threatens the world with nukes and demands "1 million dollars". In the early 1960s they still had real silver dollars in circulation.
Monday, June 15, 2015
There is a general pattern for the stages of hyperinflation. This can also be viewed as the stages of the "death of a fiat currency". Money can be seen as serving 3 roles. It is a medium of exchange, it is a store of value, and it is a unit of accounting. As we move through the stages of hyperinflation the money gradually gives up these 3 roles. Once it has given up all 3, it is dead.
- Government spending gets out of control to where deficit is 40% or more of spending and debt is over 80% of GNP. If this is for a war that the markets believe will be won and ended so that the government can make drastic cuts in spending then there is some wiggle room in these numbers.
- This goes on for a couple years and investors move towards shorter term bonds.
- It becomes clear the deficit is not going back down.
- The central bank starts buying up government debt with newly made money. If they are not naturally inclined to do this the government changes the laws or people running the central bank. For the rest of this section I will write as if the central bank were just part of the government and ignore bond certificates printed by the government and handed to the central bank as these will become worthless anyway. With this simplification I will just say, "the government prints money".
- There is capital flight out of that currency and bond sales fail. If the government let bond interest rates rise to attract bond buyers the interest payments on the debt would be huge compared to taxes collected, so they keep interest rates down by printing more money. However, the private investors become less and less inclined to "roll over" their government bonds.
- Government is forced to print money to cover their budget and inflation picks up. The more bonds coming due the worse the printing is. Many short term bonds can make for huge amounts of printing, even more than the regular budget.
- Some people notice prices going up and spend their money before prices go up more, even for things they don't need yet. The velocity of money picks up. People start to realize that the local currency is not a good store of value, though still used for transactions. Some people start to use foreign currencies or gold as a store of value.
- So many people take money out of their bank accounts and exchange it for a foreign currency, or gold, or just buy something that banks are in danger of going under. So the government often freezes bank accounts. This is very bad for the account holders, both because times are hard and they can't get their money and also because by the time they are able to get it their money it is worth much less.
- Wages and prices become indexed to something more stable, like a foreign currency or gold. So the local currency is losing the "unit of account" function. Wages become paid more often, like weekly or daily instead of monthly. The velocity of money picks up more.
- People start to use a foreign currency or gold as store of value, even though government may forbid it. The black market starts in currency exchange.
- Interest rates are very high and loans are for much shorter periods. Loans may be for a couple months instead of 30 years. Hyperinflation makes for hard times and many people are forced to sell their their land or house. Because of these things the real prices for things usually bought with long term loans can drop in terms of something like gold. Houses may usually be bought with a bag of some foreign currency. Real estate is very different during hyperinflation and normal times.
- People start to use barter or a foreign currency or gold for trade, even though government forbids it. This is a growing black market for commerce. If you trade a fish you caught for some potatoes your friend grew, neither of you is paying any taxes on the deal. In general once people are breaking the law by using a foreign currency for trade they don't pay any taxes on trade either. The black market is tax free.
- Being tax free and with better store of value the black market eventually grows larger than the legal market. People no longer worry about the government requirement to use local paper currency, enforcement is impossible.
- A business that follows the law and sells for regulated prices in the local currency can not buy enough new inventory and soon goes out of business. This makes the percentage of the economy that is black market go up.
- People start to not want to accept the local paper money. Regular taxes are down because hyperinflation has devastated the economy and much of the economy is now in the "black market". The government is finding it hard to buy things by printing money, as so much of the economy has moved to the black market. It is finding it hard to pay employees enough for them to live comfortably even though it keeps printing more all the time. The government is losing economic power. Tax collectors may be skipping work to tend to their own vegetable garden. There is a very real risk of the government failing at this step.
- At this point the government has some hard choices if it is not going to fail. It needs to do something so that the "black market" is legalized and taxable and deficits are nearly eliminated. It could just legalize a foreign currency or gold. But then it would forever give up on collecting any "inflation tax". It could get rid of budget deficits and stop printing money. However, people will still fear that it could start again at any time and so be hesitant to use that money. I think the most frequent end to hyperinflation is by making a new fiat money but with enough governmental changes that deficits and inflation are under control and people will use the new money. If they switch to a new currency then the old money is no longer used as a store of value, or unit of account, or even as a medium of exchange. It has died.
If you understand hyperinflation and think your country is at risk, how should you prepare?
Bug-OutIf it is just the country you are in, leaving that country and going somewhere else is a reasonable strategy. However, I think that we could see all the reserve currencies get hyperinflation, the Yen, Euro, Pound, and the Dollar. Since the reserve currencies are the backing for the other currencies, if they go, then all paper money is in trouble. If a government had a balanced budget, the currency could just go down till it gets to where the total value of the currency is equal to the total value of the gold a central bank has. However, since governments run deficits, we should expect continued money printing and continued devaluation. There may not be anyplace that is immune from hyperinflation this time. In past hyperinflations, Bug-Out was a reasonable strategy, but it may not work this time.
SecurityHyperinflation is not usually a Mad Max situation, but there usually is some increase in crime. So guns and general home security are more important. There are books and websites on this topic. There are many things you can do to improve home security. Good fences and gates, dogs, solid doors and windows, window bars, cameras, lights, alarms, etc. If hyperinflation becomes world wide, the security problem could be much worse than in a normal hyperinflation.
Supplies of Food etc.Governments usually put on price controls and make shortages of all sorts of things. It is simple micro-economics. If you have an artificial government legislated price, the supply does not equal demand. Because of this, having some stuff stored up ahead of time can make a huge different. Food and water are good things to have. Life is better with toilette paper, laundry soap, etc. Today you can probably afford to buy a "one year supply of food" and, if there is hyperinflation, it could be a lifesaver. It is easy now to buy a big tank, fill it with water, and put in a bit of bleach so it can last a long time. In the future, just getting water could be hard.
If your currency is dropping fast, then you are better off buying extra canned goods than holding the currency. Eventually you will eat the food and by that time it would cost far more. After years of hyperinflation in Argentina, people built far larger pantries. It is good to be able to store a bunch of canned goods at home during hyperinflation. It is better than money in the bank.
FarmingUnder government price controls, farmers can often not sell their food for enough to buy supplies for the next crop. It is often better for them and their family to just keep what food they grow, or only do direct trades for other food, labor, needed equipment, fuel, gold, etc. However, when the farmers don't bring their food to town to sell at artificially low prices, often the government, or the public and some police, will come and take the food. The real problem is the worthless money and price controls, but the government can easily redirect public anger toward the farmers. After the government passes a new law against "hording", it is easy to get people angry that while there is a shortage of food a farmer is "illegally hording food". Note that there are no laws against hording before price controls mess things up.
Gold and SilverOver time a hyperinflating currency is accepted less and less. Gold and silver hold their value and are accepted more and more over time. There is probably someone who would trade them for the local currency if you need local currency. If there is hyperinflation, by the time you trade in your gold you will get far more local currency than if you had just saved some currency instead of gold.
Some people think things will be so bad that nobody would give up their food for gold that you can't eat. This is not correct. Trade still goes on, even if it has to be black market. In a French hyperinflation people kept trading for gold even when the penalty was losing your head. There will always be people who have more than enough of one thing and not enough of something else. Imagine one person grows potatoes and someone else who raises chickens, they both could be interested in trading. They may trade directly with each other or for gold and use gold to buy the other.
Bitcoin for Internet Purchases or Store of ValueGovernments put on capital controls so money can no longer flow freely in and out of a country. They also put on official government exchange rates, which you won't be able to get in the direction you want. Because of this your credit card that used to be able to order anything on the Internet will no longer be able to buy things. A nice way around this problem is to use Bitcoin. You can use Bitcoin to buy things on the Internet even when their are capital controls stopping the normal methods for International payments. You could have to pay substantial taxes to get your order through customs, but they seem to usually allow things in or nobody will be ordering anything.
As with gold and silver, where there is hyperinflation, there will probably be someone not too far away that is trading bitcoins to/from the local currency, even if it is against the law. So getting some Bitcoin ahead of time, or during the hyperinflation, could work well both for Internet purchases and as a store of value that you can convert back to local currency as needed.
Investment OptionsIf hyperinflation comes, bonds are the worst thing to hold. To get the present value of the bond, the future value is discounted by the projected inflation rate over the time till maturity. If there is high inflation and many years, the bond can be discounted to almost nothing. If in the first 6 months the currency is down 25%, a 20 year bond could be down by more than a factor of 1,000.
Cash is not good to hold as it is dropping, though not nearly as fast as long term bonds. Governments may freeze bank accounts, so money in bank accounts could end up trapped for many months and worth far less by the time it can be taken out.
Stocks are not safe because governments usually make life very hard for companies, with price controls and other laws. If all your costs are going up fast and the price you can sell at is fixed by law, your company will be in trouble. Many companies will go under.
Rental properties are particularly bad during hyperinflation. The government rent controls keep rents fixed. At the same time the costs for running the property are going up fast. People view the landlord as rich and so he gets little sympathy for his problem of costs going up faster than income. It is not good to be a landlord during hyperinflation and rental properties can sell for crazy low real prices.
If it is just one country, then selling everything you own in that country and investing in another country is a good strategy, like leaving. However, it may not be limited to one country this time.
If you can borrow at a really low fixed interest rate for a long period and buy some real estate, this could be a good move. After hyperinflation destroys the value of money, you pay off the balance of the debt with worthless money. You need to be sure you can keep the payments up till hyperinflation hits. It does not seem possible to tell exactly when it will hit, so you need to be able to do this for some time.
Gold and silver have held their value for thousands of years and it is a safe bet they will continue to do so.
Backup TransportationIf there is hyperinflation and price controls, you may not be able to buy gas sometimes. A sturdy bicycle with some big baskets could be very handy.
Solar ElectricityUtility electricity usually keeps working, most of the time. This time may be worse. Having solar to be able to run a fridge, lights, computers, or charge an electric scooter, electric car, or cellphone, could be very useful.
Ocean Going Solar HomeIf I had the money, I would make a solar/electric ocean safe house. With a watermaker and food storage you could be fine for a long time no matter what happened anywhere.
Tuesday, June 2, 2015
On this blog I have a bunch of posts that could be made into an interesting book on hyperinflation.
Some of the key ones are:
- Positive Feedback Theory of Hyperinflation
- CMMT - Cate's Modern Monetary Theory
- Hyperinflation Explained Many Different Ways
- How We Know High Inflation is Coming
- Stages of Hyperinflation
- How to Prepare for Hyperinflation
- parts of Krugman's Missing Model
- combined with Simulating Hyperinflation
- Hyperinflation FAQ
If I could find a partner to turn this content into a book, I expect it could make some money for both of us. I am looking for someone with the following:
- Experience writing a book
- Experience self publishing
- Experience getting book onto Amazon.
- An understanding of Austrian economics.
- Preferably living outside USA
- Willing to work for share of profits or to get paid after book is on Amazon
If you are interested or know someone who might be, please contact me at firstname.lastname@example.org.